Always the Catch of the day!

Dinner Menu

Starters

Crab Dip
Loaded with crab and served fondue style with assorted crackers and bread.
$9.25
Seafood Nachos
Only at the Bay! Plenty of tasty shrimp, scallops, crab meat and melted cheese - with a garish of scallions and diced tomato "South of the Border" style.
$10.59
Calamari
Gently fried in our own special blend of seasonings, served with marinara sauce
$9.50
Mozzarella Sticks
$5.99
Onion Rings
Served with chipotle ranch dipping sauce.
$5.79
Chicken Tenders
Served with honey mustard, BBQ or sweet & sour sauces.
$6.99
Crab Pretzel
A huge baked soft pretzel smothered with melted cheese and crab meat. Is your mouth watering yet?
$8.99
Coconut Shrimp
Delicious coconut battered shrimp served with delicious citrus dipping sauce.
$8.79
Buffalo Wings
Served with crisp celery sticks and bleu cheese or ranch.
(10) $8.49
Platter (16) $12.79
Available Regular, Hot, Atomic, BBQ or Jack Daniels
Price in description
Mushroom Imperial
Fresh caps filled with our own crab imperial and baked 'til golden.
$9.29
Boat Load of Mussels
Steamed with scampi butter.
$10.59
Oysters (in season)
Raw or steamed Chesapeake Bay oysters with drawn butter
1 dozen - $13.99
1/2 dozen - $7.99
Chincoteague - Market Price
Blue Points - Market Price
Price in description
B.C. Sampler
Our delicious combination of Steamed Shrimp, Clams, Mussels and Mushroom Imperial.
$10.99
Shrimp Cocktail
Jumbo gulf shrimp served with a zesty cocktail sauce.
$7.79
U-Peel Shrimp (no sauce)
Prepared with Bay City's secret recipe, the best around! Served hot or cold.
Market Price (1/2 pound)
Price in description
Barbequed Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp wrapped in smoked bacon and smothered in our tangy sauce.
$7.99
Barbequed Scallops
Scallops wrapped in smoke bacon and smothered in our tangy sauce.
$8.25
Clams
Just some spacing Just some spacing Just some spacing
Steamed $6.99 (dozen)
On the Halfshell $4.59 (1/2 dozen)
Price in description

Soup Kettle

Crab Soup
Just some spacing Just some spacing Just some spacing
As only we can prepare it!
Bowl - $4.25
Cup - $2.99
Price in description
Clam Chowder
New England style loaded with fresh clams
Bowl - $4.25
Cup - $2.99
Price in description
Ham & Bean
Just some spacing Just some spacing Just some spacing
A hearty local favorite!
Bowl - $3.59
Cup - $2.59
Price in description
B.C. French Onion
A crock of sweet onion soup topped with mozzarella - then baked to golden brown perfection.
$5.25

Great Greens

Steak Salad
Tender sliced steak and Lyonaisse red potatoes tossed with baby field greens and bleu cheese with a smoked portabella and garlic vinaigrette
$11.99
Caribbean Shrimp Salad
Grilled shrimp over baby salad greens topped with toasted coconut, cashews and mandarin oranges with a touch of mango vinaigrette.
$11.59
Southwestern Chicken Ceaser
Seasoned chargrilled chicken breast served atop a classic Ceaser salad.
$9.29
Chef Salad Bowl
A large bed of crisp lettuce topped with ham, turkey, Swiss and American cheeses, pickled egg, fresh tomato wedges, carrot, cucumber, sweet red onion and radish.
$9.59
Garden Salad
$3.29
Shrimp Salad Bowl
Accented with our tasty shrimp salad and steamed whole shrimp.
$10.99
Spinach Salad
A classic!! Crisp leaf spinach, freshly sliced mushroom, boiled egg and chopped bacon topped with crisp croutons and our hot bacon dressing.

Dressings:
House, Oil & Vinegar, French, 1000 Island, Ranch, Pepper Parmesan, Golden Italian, Bleu Cheese, Fat Free Ranch, French and Italian
$5.99

Bay City Classics

Imperial Crab
The finest Maryland lump crabmeat mixed carefully with special seasoning and spices, baked to bring forth the natural flavor.
$19.99
Combination Seafood
A blending of the finest seafood; shrimp, oysters, fried clams, fresh tender scallops, succulent crab cake, and a delicious fish fillet.
Available broiled or fried.
(Broiled - Receive mussels instead of oysters.)
No substitutions
$23.99
Stuffed Whole Flounder
Fresh whole flounder stuffed with lump imperial crab, broiled or fried. May we remind you - whole fish have bones, but have exceptional flavor!
We have flounder fillets upon request.
$21.99
Stuffed Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp, butterflied, stuffed with fresh backfin crabmeat, lightly broiled to perfection.
$19.50
Crab Cakes
Two Crab cakes made from the finest choice backfin crabmeat, broiled or fried golden brown - delicious!
Half Portion - $11.79
$18.99
Crab Cakes Bay City Style
Two Freshly made crab cakes, dipped in our tempura batter, available fried only.
Half Portion - $11.99
$19.50
Fried Shrimp Bay City Style
Large shrimp butterflied, dipped in our tempura batter to seal in the fresh succulent taste as only our chef can prepare
$14.59

Entrees

Atlantic Salmon Monte Carlo
Fresh tender salmon served atop a delicious buttered dill cream sauce.
Half Portion - $11.99
$17.99
Alaskan Snow Crab Legs
Over 1¼ pound steamed to mouthwatering perfection.
$18.99
Softshell Crab
Two Eastern shore softshell crabs available, deep fried or sautéed.
Market Price
Fresh North Atlantic Fish
Mild, white and flaky. Offered fried or broiled.
$11.50
Fried Oysters
Fresh Chesapeake Bay oysters lightly padded and fried to perfection.
Half Portion - $11.25
$15.99
Bay City Stir Fry
Chicken, shrimp or both served with steamed vegetables and oriental sauce over rice.
Served with one side.
Vegetarian available
$13.99
Scallops
Tender sea scallops dipped in milk and lightly coated and fried in pure vegetable oil or broiled to a golden brown in lemon butter.
Half Portion - Market Price
Market Price
Fried Shrimp
Eight large shrimp butterflied, dipped in milk and egg and lightly coated with our special mixture, always fresh.
Half Portion - $11.25
$14.59
Fried Clams
Bay clams dipped in egg and milk and rolled in a special batter of combined herbs and seasonings.
$10.99

Pasta

Info:
Pasta dishes are served with your choice of a House or Spinach Salad with warm rolls and butter.
Spaghetti with Meat or Marinara Sauce
An old family recipe - thick, zesty and perfectly spiced
$9.50
Crab & Shrimp Alfredo
Shrimp and lump crab meat sautéed with wild mushrooms, tomatoes, spinach and shallots in a rich cream sauce
$17.99
Seafood Sicily
Shrimp, crab meat and bay scallops sautéed with baby spinach and marinara sauce and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese
$18.99
Chicken Alfredo
Pan seared chicken breast tossed with spring vegetables in a buttered garlic cream sauce
$15.99
Chicken Parmesan
Delicately sautéed chicken breast topped with melted cheeses and marinara sauce with a side of spaghetti
$13.99

Poultry

Info:
The following dinners consist of hot bread and your choice sides:
Tossed Salad, Spinach Salad, Baked Potato, French Fries, Cole Slaw, Applesauce, Red Beet Eggs, Cottage Cheese, Vegetable Du Jour or Rice Pilaf Many dishes can be prepared
HEART SMART.
Please ask your server.
Fried Chicken
Half a chicken fried in our own savory blend of herbs and spices.
Served with two sides. It’s great!
$9.59
Chicken Sweet-n-Sour
Sliced chicken breast in a delicious sweet-n-sour sauce served over rice pilaf with mixed vegetables.
Served with one side
$11.99
Grilled Chicken Cordon Bleu
Grilled chicken and Smith Field ham topped with herbal havarti cheese and Mornay sauce on a bed of spinach.
Served with one side
$14.99

Little Catches

Little Catches
12 and under please.
Served with French fries or applesauce and a beverage.

Cheese burger

Chicken Tenders

Spaghetti

Shrimp Basket

Clam Basket

Grilled Cheese

PB & J

Your choice - $5.79
Price in description

Landscapes

Info:
All steaks are available with sautéed mushrooms or onions or blackened in a Cajun blend for a minimal charge.
Porterhouse Steak
1 1/2 lb. prime cut - a great feast.
$23.99
Prime Rib
(Available after 4 pm)
Admiral’s cut - 1 lb. slow roasted, thick and flavorful - $19.99
Captain’s cut - 3/4 lb. and just as
flavorful - $17.99
Both sizes are available Cajun blackened - enjoy!
Price in description
Bay City Steak
1lb - Very similar to a T-bone steak. True hand-cut bone-in flavor.
$18.99
Filet Mignon
3/4 lb. - our finest! Thick, tender
and juicy - $23.99
1/2 lb. for our smaller
appetites - $18.99
Price in description
Filet St. Michael’s
8 oz. filet mignon topped with shrimp, lobster, scallops and havarti cheese on a bed of tomato coulis and sautèed spinach.
Wonderful!
$26.99
Sirloin Steak
16 oz. - A great steak for a great appetite
$15.99
Hamburger Steak
3/4 lb of fresh ground choice sirloin served with a rich pan gravy. Only the best for you.
$9.59
Ham Steak
3/4 lb - Thick and Flavorful. Available grilled or baked
(In a Honey Mustard glaze upon request)
$12.59
Ribs, Ribs, Ribs
Baby back pork ribs slow roasted, marinated in our special spicy sauce and grilled perfectly.
Half Rack - $12.99 | Full Rack $18.99
Price in description

Perfect Couples

Plan Your Own Feast! Pick Any Two
• Top Cut 12 oz. Marinated Sirloin Steak

• Alaskan Snow Crab Legs

• Fried Shrimp

• Grilled Atlantic Salmon (Monte Carlo)

• Gourmet Imperial Crab Cake

• Bay Scallops Au Gratin

• Grilled Chicken Cordon Bleu

• Shrimp Scampi

• BBQ Shrimp

• BBQ Scallops

• Ribs, Ribs, Ribs - 1/2 Rack BBQ
$18.99

Lobster Lovers

Whole Maine Lobster
1 1/4 - 1 1/2 lb succulent whole Maine lobster selected from our tank and steamed to perfection.

Market Price • Stuffed with crab Imperial add $6.99

Price in description
Lobster Tail
A large 12 oz. tail broiled with butter and garnished with a fresh lemon wedge.
$32.99
Stuffed Lobster Tail
An 8 oz. tail stuffed with lump imperial crab
$39.99
Surf & Turf
Admiral's - 12 oz. lobster tail with a 12 oz. filet mignon - $49.99
Captain's - 8 oz. lobster tail with an 8 oz. filet mignon - $34.99
Price in description

Sides

Accompanying Dishes
Just some spacing Just some spacing Just some spacing
Rice Pilaf
Red Beet Eggs
Spinach Salad
French Fries
Cole Slaw
Applesauce
Cottage Cheese
Vegetable of the Day
House Salad
Sautéed Mushrooms - $2.50
Sautéed Onions - $2.25
Mozzarella Sticks - $5.99
Onion Rings - $2.99

Gourmet Burgers

Info:
1/2 pound ground sirloin garnished with lettuce, tomato and pickle.
Served with choice of French fries or cole slaw.
The Patty Melt
Grilled sourdough rye, Swiss, sautéed onions and 1000 Island
$7.99
The Classic
Nothing fancy - big juicy and tasty with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$7.29
The Wisconsin Triple
Monterey Jack, American and Swiss
$7.59
Bacon, Cheese & More Bacon
Any questions?
$7.99
The Fajita Burger
No roll here! Chopped sirloin grilled with Cajun spices served over tortilla chips, lettuce, salsa, cheese & sour cream.
$8.99
Black & Bleu Burger
Rolled in our own special seasonings, seared in a skillet and smothered with our bleu cheese sauce.
$8.79

Sandwiches

Info:
All sandwiches served on your choice of bread with kosher dill pickle and choice of fries or cole slaw.
Substitute a tossed salad.
North Atlantic Fish Sandwich
Offered broiled or fried on toast with cole slaw, lettuce & tomato.
$7.99
Crab Melt
Fresh crab salad smothered with melted cheeses, served on pretzel bread with a sliced of tomato.
$9.99
Crab Cake Sandwich
Made fresh daily from the best backfin crabmeat.
$9.79
Shrimp Salad
We make the best! Rich & chunky with a touch of spice.
$8.79
Soft Shell Crab
Served on toast with lettuce and tomato
$9.50
Chicken Teriyaki
Boneless fresh chicken breast marinated and carefully grilled.
Served on French bread with lettuce and tomato.
$7.99
California Cheese Steak
Sliced steak topped with spaghetti sauce, sautèed onions, peppers, mushrooms & melted cheese.
$7.99
Open Face Grilled Prime Rib
6 oz. tender steak perfectly grilled and served with lettuce, tomato and fries.
$9.99
Hot Roast Beef
With French fries.
$6.99

Beverages

Fresh Brewed Coffee & Tea
$2.25
Soft Drinks
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mountain Dew
Free Refills
$2.25
Raspberry Iced Tea
$2.25

Frozen Delights

Daiquiris
Strawberry, Raspberry, Banana, Peach
Mud Slide
Bailey's, Kahlua, Vodka & Cream
Toasted Almond
Ameretto, Kahlua & Cream
Coladas
Strawberry, Raspberry, Kahlua, Classic Piña
Dreamsicle
An ice-creamy Orange
Strawberry Banana Split
It's our secret and delicious!
Mounds Freeze
Chocolate Rum, Pineapple & Coconut Flavor, Ice Cream - Fantastic!
Margaritas
Peach, Raspberry, Strawberry, Banana
White Russian
Vodka, Kahlua & Cream
Nuts ‘n Berries
Raspberry, Frangelica & Cream

Non-Alcoholic Fruit Smoothies

Non-Alcoholic Fruit Smoothies
A fantastic blend of all natural fruit flavors and real ice cream. Flavor beyond your imagination.
Strawberry, Raspberry, Banana, Peach, Piña Colada.

Coffees

Italian
Sambuca
Baileys
Irish
Mexican
Kahlua
Irish
Bushmills Irish Whiskey
Millionaires
Brandy, Kahlua, Baileys, Grand Marnier

Wines by the Glass

Wines by the Glass
White Zinfandel
Pinot Grigio
Moscato
Chardonnay
Carbernet Sauvignon
Merlot
Lambrusco


We also have a Vintage Wine List available for your dining pleasure.